Publication | Book Chapter

Theory and Philosophy of Law

Proportionality in its narrow sense and measuring the intensity of restrictions on fundamental rights

Book title / Magazine:
Proportionality in Law: An Analytical Perspective
LPL Author(s):
Jorge Silva Sampaio
Within the scope of the Project:
Lisbon Legal Theory
Research Areas:
Theory of Law
Bibliographic reference:
Sampaio, J.S. (2018). Proportionality in Its Narrow Sense and Measuring the Intensity of Restrictions on Fundamental Rights. In: Duarte, D., Silva Sampaio, J. (eds) Proportionality in Law. Springer, Cham.
Research Group(s):
Theory and Philosophy of Law
978-3-319-89647-2
Publishing company: Springer
Year: 2018

Synopsis

Within the criticism that has been made of the principle of proportionality, I intend to contribute to the deepening and improvement of what is understood as the test of proportionality in its narrow sense, which has been the main target of critics. Firstly, I will come up with a conceptual framework which I understand will allow for a better understanding of the norm of proportionality. Secondly, from an analytical perspective, I will explain my understanding of the structure of the norm of proportionality. And, thirdly, I will focus on proportionality in its narrow sense and especially on the Alexy’s weight formula. Here, however, I will frame this effect of proportionality in the light of the philosophy of measurement to explain what is truly done within the scope of this principle; then I will try to reconstruct the metaphor of the weight formula in the light of the compressive strength phenomenon. Finally, I will move on to a mapping of criteria that provide legal operators with a better justification of the intensity measurement of restrictions made to the fundamental rights’ norms.

Lisbon Public Law Research Centre

O que procura?

Ex. Investigadores, Eventos, Publicações…